Salvator Mundi - not Leonardo, but Luini?

August 7 2018

Image of Salvator Mundi - not Leonardo, but Luini?

Picture: Christie's

An Oxford academic, Matthew Landrus, has declared that the Salvator Mundi sold last year for $450m is not by Leonardo da Vinci, but Benardino Luini. From The Guardian:

“This is a Luini painting,” Landrus said. “By looking at the various versions of Leonardo’s students’ works, one can see that Luini paints just like that work you see in the Salvator Mundi.”

He said between 5% and 20% of the painting was by Leonardo, and that Luini was the “primary painter”. [...]

Landrus said: “I can prove that Luini painted most of that painting. A comparison of Luini’s paintings with the Salvator Mundi will be sufficient evidence.”

Describing Luini as one of Leonardo’s two most talented studio assistants (the other was Giovanni Antonio Boltraffio), he has compared Luini’s Christ among the Doctors in the National Gallery with the Salvator Mundi.

The evidence has led him to conclude that Luini was “the only reasonable candidate for much of the authorship”. He added: “By traditional standards, we can call it ‘a Leonardo studio’ painting.”

Landus highlighted stylistic similarities, including the depiction of the gold bands and the fabric on the robes, saying: “One sees a similar construction on both of those gold bands and on the way the drapery is done. Luini did other paintings that had very good gold tracery in them. Also Christ’s face in both paintings has very similar modelling and, while the hairstyles are slightly different, the approaches are quite similar. Also, the shoulders on Christ are very similar.”

Pointing to a photograph of the Salvator Mundi before its extensive restoration, he said: “There’s a lot of missing paint in certain sections. So it really does add to the discussion about how overpainted it is.”

Landus believes that, if Leonardo’s hand is there, it is in the sophistication of the “sfumato technique, the subtle gradations of shading that avoid perceptible contours or dramatic shifts in tonal values”.

The key painting for Landrus that links the Salvator Mundi to Luini is the National Gallery's Christ Among the Doctors. The construction of important areas such as the face and hands seems to me to be rather different; but this is not at all my area. Either way, on a purely empirical level, I don't agree that simply comparing the Salvator Mundi with known works by Luini is 'sufficient evidence' to prove Luini's authorship, when so many other respected scholars say otherwise.

The new book will be out in September.

Notice to "Internet Explorer" Users

You are seeing this notice because you are using Internet Explorer 6.0 (or older version). IE6 is now a deprecated browser which this website no longer supports. To view the Art History News website, you can easily do so by downloading one of the following, freely available browsers:

Once you have upgraded your browser, you can return to this page using the new application, whereupon this notice will have been replaced by the full website and its content.